Vermilion, Ohio, is home to a thriving pizza scene with options to suit every taste and need. To help you find the best pizza spot, we’ve evaluated every pizza place in town based on a set of key factors: Taste, Variety, Atmosphere, Value, and Convenience. Additionally, we’ve tagged each place as a “Fan Favorite” or not, based on feedback from the community. Here’s how each one stacks up:
Pizza Galley (Fan Favorite)
Pizza Galley is a family-owned and operated pizza joint that has become a staple in the Vermilion community. Known for its bold, creative specialty pizzas, it has earned a reputation for quality and consistency. While it doesn’t have a full dining room, the couple of tables available provide a cozy option for quick meals, and its carryout and delivery services are popular among locals.
Address: 4412 Liberty Ave, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 963-0177
Hours:
- Wednesday–Thursday: 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
- Friday–Saturday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM
- Taste: Pizza Galley is celebrated for its unique specialty pizzas, such as the “Truffle Butter” and “Slow-Smoked BBQ.” The bold flavors and high-quality ingredients make it a standout choice.
- Variety: The menu includes creative specialty pizzas, calzones, and salads. While options are slightly limited compared to others, the focus on quality ensures a satisfying meal.
- Atmosphere: With a couple of tables, Pizza Galley is all about the convenience of takeout. This limits its ambiance but makes it perfect for enjoying at home.
- Value: The prices are fair, especially considering the gourmet nature of their pizzas. It’s a great choice for those looking to splurge a bit on unique flavors.
- Convenience: As a carryout-focused restaurant, Pizza Galley is highly accessible for quick and easy orders.
Jim’s Pizza Box (Fan Favorite)
Jim’s Pizza Box has been a cornerstone of Vermilion’s pizza scene for years. Renowned for its classic approach to pizza, this family-friendly spot delivers a warm, welcoming atmosphere and a menu that caters to all tastes. It’s a favorite for both locals and visitors looking for a reliable, satisfying meal.
Address: 4503 Liberty Ave, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 595-1025
Hours:
- Tuesday–Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday–Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Taste: Jim’s Pizza Box delivers classic, satisfying pizzas with fresh ingredients. The Deluxe and Meatzza pizzas are fan favorites for their hearty toppings and rich flavors.
- Variety: From pizzas and subs to wings and salads, Jim’s menu is extensive and caters to diverse tastes.
- Atmosphere: With a welcoming, family-friendly dining area, Jim’s is ideal for casual meals with friends or loved ones.
- Value: Generous portions at reasonable prices make it a solid option for families and groups.
- Convenience: With dine-in, carryout, and delivery options, Jim’s provides flexible dining experiences.
Woodstock Cafe (Fan Favorite)
Woodstock Cafe is a gem in Vermilion for those seeking artisan-style pizzas paired with a bohemian charm. This spot stands out for its creative approach to pizza-making and its inviting, laid-back environment. Whether you’re looking for a unique flavor or a relaxed dining experience, Woodstock Cafe delivers on both fronts.
Address: 665 Main St, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 967-7687
Hours:
- Tuesday–Thursday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Friday–Saturday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Sunday–Monday: Closed
- Taste: Woodstock excels in artisan pizzas with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The “Psychedelic Pie” and “Veg-Head” are standout options, showcasing their creative flair.
- Variety: While the menu focuses on artisan pizzas, it also includes fresh salads and other light fare, appealing to a niche audience.
- Atmosphere: The cafe’s cozy, bohemian vibe makes it a great spot for a laid-back meal or a casual date night.
- Value: Slightly pricier than some other options, but the quality and creativity of the dishes justify the cost.
- Convenience: Primarily dine-in with limited hours, making it best for those looking to savor their meal in-house.
Lucy’s Bar and Grill (Fan Favorite)
Lucy’s Bar and Grill brings a vibrant energy to Vermilion’s dining scene. With its Brooklyn-style sourdough crusts and adventurous menu, it’s a destination for bold flavors and unique culinary experiences. The lively atmosphere and diverse menu make it a standout for anyone looking for a fun night out.
Address: 4523 Liberty Ave, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 963-7603
Hours:
- Tuesday–Wednesday: 4:00 PM – 9:30 PM
- Thursday: 4:00 PM – 11:00 PM
- Friday–Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Taste: Lucy’s pizzas are known for their sourdough crusts and unique topping combinations. Favorites include the “Kentucky Cobra” and other creative options.
- Variety: Beyond pizza, Lucy’s menu features pierogies, burgers, and other bold dishes, making it a versatile dining choice.
- Atmosphere: With a lively and energetic vibe, Lucy’s is perfect for a fun night out with friends or family.
- Value: Prices are fair for the high-quality ingredients and diverse menu offerings.
- Convenience: Offers dine-in and carryout, but the atmosphere is best experienced in person.
Smokin’ Joe’s (Fan Favorite)
Smokin’ Joe’s is a beloved spot in Vermilion, known for its bold, smoky flavors and hearty menu options. The BBQ pizza is a standout favorite among locals, but its consistently robust offerings have earned it a loyal fanbase.
Address: 5309 Liberty Ave, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 967-3724
Hours:
- Monday–Thursday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday–Saturday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Taste: Known for their BBQ pizza, Smokin’ Joe’s delivers robust, satisfying flavors that stand out.
- Variety: The menu includes pizzas, wings, and other comfort foods, offering something for everyone.
- Atmosphere: Primarily a carryout and delivery spot, Smokin’ Joe’s focuses more on convenience than dine-in ambiance.
- Value: Competitive pricing and hearty portions make it a great option for budget-conscious diners.
- Convenience: Delivery and carryout options are reliable and efficient, making it an easy choice for a quick meal.
Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza combines the reliability of a chain with the flavor and quality that Vermilion locals appreciate. Known for its consistently delicious crusts and sauces, Marco’s has become a trusted option for families and pizza enthusiasts alike.
Address: 4425 Liberty Ave, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 967-7555
Hours:
- Monday–Thursday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
- Friday–Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
- Taste: Marco’s focuses on traditional flavors with standout crust and sauce. Their pizzas are consistently satisfying.
- Variety: The menu includes a wide range of pizzas, subs, wings, and salads, catering to all tastes.
- Atmosphere: As a chain, Marco’s is more about convenience than ambiance, but it delivers on quality.
- Value: Family-friendly pricing and large portion sizes make it a great choice for feeding groups.
- Convenience: With extended hours and delivery options, Marco’s is a reliable pick for late-night cravings or quick meals.
Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza is a household name that has become a staple for quick and convenient pizza options in Vermilion. With its budget-friendly deals and speedy delivery, it’s a practical choice for weeknight dinners and late-night cravings.
Address: 5329 Liberty Ave, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 967-0300
Hours:
- Sunday–Thursday: 10:30 AM – 12:00 AM
- Friday–Saturday: 10:30 AM – 1:00 AM
- Taste: Domino’s delivers consistent quality with fan favorites like their hand-tossed crust and specialty pizzas.
- Variety: The menu includes pizzas, pasta, sandwiches, and desserts, making it versatile.
- Atmosphere: Primarily focused on carryout and delivery, with minimal dine-in options.
- Value: Affordable prices and frequent deals make Domino’s a budget-friendly option.
- Convenience: Open late with fast delivery, it’s perfect for busy weeknights or last-minute pizza runs.
Papa Joe’s Pizza (Fan Favorite)
Papa Joe’s Pizza is a classic, no-frills establishment that has served Vermilion families for years. Its focus on simplicity and quality has made it a go-to spot for those seeking straightforward, delicious pizzas.
Address: 5590 Liberty Ave, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 967-7330
Hours:
- Sunday–Thursday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday–Saturday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Taste: Papa Joe’s offers straightforward, delicious pizzas that appeal to all ages.
- Variety: While the menu focuses on pizza, the quality ensures satisfaction.
- Atmosphere: Primarily a carryout spot, with a focus on quick service and consistent results.
- Value: Affordable and reliable, making it a top choice for families or casual meals.
- Convenience: Carryout-focused, with easy ordering and quick turnaround times.
Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut brings its national reputation for nostalgic flavors and wide-ranging options to Vermilion. Known for its stuffed crusts and hearty pan pizzas, it’s a practical and popular choice for families and pizza lovers alike.
Address: 4272 East Liberty Ave, Vermilion, OH 44089
Phone Number: (440) 963-0711
Hours:
- Monday–Thursday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM
- Saturday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM
- Taste: Pizza Hut delivers classic flavors, with options like stuffed crust and pan pizzas that many love.
- Variety: The menu includes pizza, pasta, wings, and desserts, offering something for everyone.
- Atmosphere: Primarily focused on carryout and delivery, with some dine-in options.
- Value: Competitive pricing and frequent deals make it a popular choice for families.
- Convenience: With delivery and carryout, Pizza Hut is accessible and reliable.
Conclusion
No matter what you’re looking for in a pizza experience, Vermilion has a spot for you. From the artisan pizzas at Woodstock Cafe to the bold flavors of Smokin’ Joe’s, each place brings its own unique flair to the table. Next time you’re craving pizza, consider these factors to find the perfect match for your occasion. After all, in Vermilion, there’s always a good reason for another slice.
